Custom Engagement Rings

Custom Engagement

Create unique engagement rings online or in-person in Provo, Utah

Design Your Own Engagement Ring

You don’t need to know a thing about jewelry to create something unforgettable. We’ll guide you step by step and help you design an affordable custom engagement ring that reflects your love.

Get Started

Schedule Your Custom Ring Consultation

Tell us what you’re imagining—even if it’s just a vibe or a photo. We’ll talk budget, timing, and style, then walk you through what’s possible. Most clients start with a free call or quick form.

Learn More

Step 1

Choose Your Diamond and Setting

We’ll meet online or at our Provo, UT studio to design your custom engagement ring. You’ll compare lab-grown, natural, Moissanite, or heirloom stones side by side and choose a setting that fits your vision and your life.

Learn More

Step 2

See Your Ring for the First Time

Once your ring is crafted, we’ll meet in person or virtually for the reveal. Many clients bring a parent or partner because it’s more than a pickup. It’s the moment your story becomes a forever ring.

Learn More

Step 3

Build Your Dream Ring

Join the Forevering Family

At Forevering, we’ve spent nearly 50 years helping couples tell their stories through custom rings. As the Rutherfords, our name stands for trust, care, and craftsmanship—and we take that seriously.

“When someone sends us their sister or their son, we show up fully. That trust means everything.”

— Bethany Rutherford, Co-owner

Let’s Design It Together

Custom Rings Without the Markup

Forevering creates timeless engagement rings with you, not for you. Every ring is made-to-order with your budget and vision in mind. That means you can spend $1,500 or $10,000 and still walk away with a ring that feels like forever.

Let’s Design It Together

You Don’t Need to Have It All Figured Out

You bring the photos, the Pinterest boards, the maybes. We’ll help you sort through the options and figure out what fits best. We’ll present diamond shapes, setting styles, metals, and lab-grown and natural or Moissanite stones side by side, so you can choose what feels right.

Round

Oval

Elongated Cushion

Emerald

Elongated Radiant

Marquise

Let's Design It Together

Ready to create your custom piece?

Our custom design process is collaborative and brings you as close to our level of expertise as possible. Here is a look at the collaborative process involved in creating a custom-made piece of jewelry. Book your consultation online or in Provo, send us your inspiration, and we’ll get started on your design.

Get Started