Start Your Journey BOOK A CONSULTATION

Custom Engagement Rings

Custom engagement rings crafted
in Provo & Lehi for real couples, real
budgets, and real love

 Let’s Create Yours
Custom Engagement Rings

Custom Engagement Rings

Begin the Process
Ready To Wear Jewelry

Ready To Wear Jewelry

Shop the Collection
Repurpose Unused Jewelry

Repurpose Unused Jewelry

Reimagine Your Jewelry
Next
Next
A ring that reflects your love

Unique Engagement Rings as Personal as Your Story

Design your own engagement ring with people who listen, who care, and who want to help you create something that feels just right. Together with Forevering Jewelry, you’ll craft an affordable custom engagement ring that celebrates your love and holds meaning for generations.
Let's Design It Together
Slide Image
Slide Image
Slide Image
Slide Image
Discovery Consultation
Discovery Consultation
Start with a short request form or a free call. We'll learn what matters to you–style, story, and pricing. Then shape a design process that fits.
Learn More
Step 1
Design and Stone Sourcing
Design and Stone Sourcing
Meet with us in person or online. We'll design your engagement ring and source lab diamonds, natural diamonds, or heirloom stones that fit your vision.
Learn More
Step 2
Engagement Ring Reveal
Engagement Ring Reveal
When your ring is ready, you’ll visit our Provo studio or meet us virtually to see it for the first time. Loved ones are always welcome to join!
Learn More
Step 3
Next
Previous

Not Sure Which Custom Ring Style You Want?  Let Us Help

We’ll walk you through the most popular diamond shapes, suggest unique engagement rings that work best for your style and budget, and help you figure out what feels right. Once you’ve landed on a diamond shape, you’ll see real options—lab-grown, natural, or Moissanite—side by side, so you can make a decision that feels good. We’ll also present band styles and metal types to match.
Round
Round
Oval
Oval
Elongated Cushion
Elongated Cushion
Emerald
Emerald
Elongated Radiant
Elongated Radiant
Marquise
Marquise
Next
Previous
See What Our Clients Are Saying...
★★★★★
“ My Wife Loves Her Ring ”
My wife really wanted a simple, yet elegant ring that fit her personality and our relationship. That is exactly what we got. Bethany was so personable and gave us countless options to choose from. Not only to choose from, but also different variation and ways to customize our rings. My wife loves her ring, and it wouldn’t be as perfect without forevering. I also got my ring from forevering. She worked so well with my wife to get the date and our initials engraved inside the ring. Forevering provided these at a cost you won’t find anywhere else. Not only is bethany great at her job, but my wife and I feel like we made a new friend with her. She is just a great person! Can’t be more grateful!

- Kaden & Mylee Bodily
- Kaden & Mylee Bodily
“ Very Accommodating ”
I loved the small one on one time with you and getting to play with all of the different ring and diamond styles! You were very accommodating and wanted us to know and see every option we had to fit our budget. I got my dream ring from you guys! I loved going there together with Karson and choosing something that I loved, it was a special date night for both of us! You sent us pictures of my ring being made from the jeweler and that was so special to see the process, time and dedication it took to make my ring! I love that u get to wear something so beautiful everyday, it’s a special reminder of the most perfect day we had!
- Emily Bodily
“ Forevering Jewelry is the place to go! ”
If you’re looking for a custom, unique ring and an intimate experience, Forevering Jewelry is the place to go! Working with them was exceptional—I shared Pinterest photos with my sisters to convey what I wanted: a princess or cushion cut with a twisted band. From there, my now-husband collaborated with the Forevering Jewelry team to create a piece that was truly one-of-a-kind and exquisite. I love knowing that my ring’s creation involved a personal touch from everyone and even includes options for future additions.
“ I will continue referring all my friends! ”
We had the BEST experience with forevering jewelry. We had been to multiple places to look for an engagement ring and we by far had the best experience here. Bethany did everything she could to ensure we got exactly what we wanted. I am in love with my ring and will be for forever!! Not only was she very accommodating, she was also very easy and pleasant to work with. We recommended forevering jewelry to my brother in law and cousin, and they both had amazing experiences. I will continue referring all my friends!
- Abbey Magleby
Next
Next

Shop Our Best Sellers

Tennis Bracelet
Tennis Bracelet
$1000
The Lacey Ring
The Lacey Ring
$1000
The Olivia Bracelet
The Olivia Bracelet
$1000
Lacey Necklace
Lacey Necklace
$1000
Next
Next
Provo, Utah Diamond Matchmaker
Bethany
With Over A Decade Of ExperienceIn Custom Designing. I'm Confident ICan Bring Your Vision To Life.
I grew up around diamonds and love stories. My parents built this business on trust, and now I get to help the next generation—young couples, newlyweds, and families—design custom engagement rings and jewelry that reflect who they are and where they come from. Whether you're starting fresh or reimagining family heirlooms, I’m here to help you create something meaningful.
Let's Design It Together
Breathe New Life Into Unused Jewelry

Heirloom Jewelry Redesign That Honors Your Past And Creates Something New

Your mom's wedding band. A gold chain from grandpa. Rings from a different life chapter. Forevering Jewelry helps you turn old jewelry into something beautiful, wearable, and deeply personal, whether that means melting pieces down or reimagining the stones into new custom rings, earrings, bracelets, and necklaces.
Let's Design It Together
Slide Image
Slide Image
Step 1
Step 1
Bring in what you have—we’ll listen, sort through it together, and talk through your redesign or jewelry buyback options with care.
Learn More
Step 1
Step 2
Step 2
We weigh, test, and evaluate your gold in-house. You choose whether to reuse it or trade in jewelry for crash or credit toward your next piece.
Learn More
Step 2
Step 3
Step 3
Your heirloom is transformed into something new—or passed on with intention. Either way, your story continues.
Learn More
Step 3
Next
Previous

Shop Most Popular

Tennis Bracelet
Tennis Bracelet
$1000
The Lacey Ring
The Lacey Ring
$1000
The Olivia Bracelet
The Olivia Bracelet
$1000
Lacey Necklace
Lacey Necklace
$1000
Next
Next
Video thumbnail

The Forevering Family Legacy

Forevering Jewelry began in 1976 when Larry and Carol Rutherford took a chance on a friend’s diamond venture. Over the years what started as a small wholesale business grew into a family-run destination for affordable custom engagement rings in Utah. Today, their daughter Bethany carries that legacy forward, helping young couples craft their forever ring, redesigning heirlooms, and creating heart-driven pieces that last.